Rise Analytics Blog

Healthy Averages Can Hide a Stressed Loan Portfolio

Written by John Wagner | (Nov 18, 2026)

The Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Finances comes out every three years, and the latest edition has a number lenders should read twice. From 2022 to the end of 2025, the share of families behind on loan payments went from about 12% to nearly 20%. That is the highest since 2010, when the country was still climbing out of the Great Recession. Families two or more months behind rose from 5% to more than 8%, and 8.6% of households now put more than 40% of their income toward debt payments, up from 6.5% in 2022.

The economy grew through this stretch, which is part of what makes the numbers odd. The gains just weren’t shared evenly. Median net worth for the top income group rose 31%. For families in the bottom quarter, it fell 6%. Across all families, average net worth rose 7% while the median rose only 2%, a sign that the wealthiest households were pulling the average up.

Lenders should take note of that gap: a portfolio can look fine on average while a real slice of it is struggling.

What Credit Union Data Shows

The NCUA’s second quarter 2026 data points in the same direction, though more gently. The delinquency rate across federally insured credit unions was 96 basis points – up 6 basis points from a year earlier – while the net charge-off ratio was 78 basis points; little changed over the year. The median credit union shows a similar drift at smaller scale, with a total delinquency rate of 69 basis points against 65 a year ago. Meanwhile the exposure keeps growing. Total loans reached $1.76 trillion, up 4.9%, and the average loan balance rose 5.2% to $19,906.

Those delinquency levels are low, and the system is well capitalized, with a net worth ratio of 11.42%. Nobody should read them as an alarm. But they are system averages, which is exactly what the Fed survey says to be careful with. Credit card delinquency, for example, edged down to 191 basis points, so the picture isn’t the same across products. Delinquency is also a lagging measure. By the time a loan shows up in it, the member has already fallen behind, and the warning signs, like a slipping credit score or a collateral value that has dropped, were usually visible well before.

Where Credit Unions Feel It

Credit unions lend to everyday members, the households most exposed to inflation and heavier payment burdens, and that pressure lands in several places at once. CECL reserves depend on forward-looking estimates, and those are only as good as the credit scores and collateral values behind them. Examiners expect consistent risk ratings, sound fair lending practices, accurate 5300 reporting and multi-dimensional portfolio analysis. And the board still wants a straight answer on portfolio quality that goes beyond a delinquency percentage.

How Grading and Enrichment Work Together

A national survey describes the climate. It can’t tell you which of your own loans are in trouble. Rise Analytics can, in a two-step approach.

The first is data enrichment. Rise Analytics refreshes member credit scores, updates auto collateral values loan by loan using the vehicle itself and brings real estate values in line with current markets. The file you have from origination is rarely the loan you hold today.

The second is loan grading. Developed with input from a former credit union chief lending officer, Rise Analytics’ approach evaluates each loan’s current credit score, how far that score has moved since origination, current loan-to-value, payment status, any modifications and whether there is a co-borrower. Each loan receives a low, medium or high rating for default risk, along with an estimate of how much of the balance would be exposed if the loan did default. Rise Analytics’ strategic lending consultants help your team interpret those findings and prioritize actions that align with your portfolio, risk tolerance and lending goals.

What Tends to Turn Up

Run across a full portfolio, the same patterns keep appearing. Average credit scores often hold steady while the share of loans rated high risk creeps up, usually concentrated in a product or two such as indirect auto or credit cards. Once vehicle values are refreshed, a number of used auto loans show a loan-to-value above 100%, meaning the member owes more than the car is worth. Loans that pair high default risk with thin or missing collateral can be pulled out and sized, so staff can reach those members earlier in the delinquency cycle.

Unfunded commitments can be checked against score migration, which flags members whose scores have dropped sharply since origination before they draw more credit. Stress scenarios show the board how reserves and net worth would hold if credit quality or collateral values slipped, which makes the risk conversation specific instead of abstract. The same data shows opportunity too. Auto borrowers nearing payoff are natural prospects for a new loan, and members with strong credit and low card utilization are good candidates for limit increases.

Making Sense of the Data

Data on its own doesn’t tell you what to do. A graded portfolio produces a lot of numbers, and reading them well takes experience. That is the part our team of lending consultants handles alongside your management team.

We start by looking past the headline figures for the concentrations and trends that deserve attention: a product line, an origination year, a dealer relationship, a group of members whose credit has slipped. Then we help your team understand what’s driving those patterns. A rising high-risk share means different things at different credit unions, so we compare against prior periods, your own strategy and your membership before drawing conclusions.

From there we get practical. That means turning collateral and credit findings into CECL inputs and assumptions you can defend to auditors and examiners, deciding what to change in underwriting, collections outreach or limit management (and what to leave alone), and preparing the story you will tell your board and your examiners. We work alongside your team to turn those findings into clear priorities, informed decisions and practical next steps.

Bottom Line

Nobody knows where the credit cycle goes from here, and you don’t need to. You need current data, a consistent view of the loans you already hold and people who can help you read it. The earlier you have those, the more room you have to act.

Connect with Rise Analytics’ lending consultants to explore how loan grading and data enrichment can help your credit union identify emerging risk, prioritize member outreach and uncover lending opportunities.

Sources: Federal Reserve Board, Survey of Consumer Finances; NCUA Quarterly Credit Union Data Summary and Quarterly U.S. Map Review, second quarter 2026.